docs: 73
This data as json
| id | lf_id | title | collection | sub_collection | entity | date | doc_type | contentType | pages | words | identifiers | records_url | body |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 73 | LF-d0f1d098253e | DOI OIG 2021-ER-002: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Grants Awarded to the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2017, Through September 30, 2019, Under… | Audits & Oversight | DOI OIG | VI Dept. of Planning and Natural Resources (DPNR) | 2022-05-20 | Audit | government-audit | 34 | 8961 | https://usvipublicrecords.com/doc?id=LF-d0f1d098253e | AUDIT Office of U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Grants Awarded to the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2017, Through September 30, 2019, Under the Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program This is a revised version of the report prepared for public release. Report No.: 2021–ER–002 May 2022 Office of Inspector General U.S. Department of the InteriorMay 20, 2022 Memorandum To: Martha Williams Director, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service From: Stephen Gregoire Acting Regional Manager, Eastern Region Digitall y signed by STEPHEN GREGOIR E Date: 2022.05. 20 15:20:17 -04'00' Subject: Final Audit Report – U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Grants Awarded to the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2017, Through September 30, 2019, Under the Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program Report No. 2021–ER–002 This report presents the results of our audit of costs claimed by the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources (Department) under grants awarded by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) through the Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program. We provided a draft of this report to the FWS. The FWS concurred with all nine recommendations and one repeat recommendation and will work with the Department to implement corrective actions. The full responses from the Department and the FWS are included in Appendix 5. We list the status of the recommendations in Appendix 6. Please provide us with a corrective action plan based on our recommendations by August 8, 2022. The plan should provide information on actions taken or planned to address each recommendation, as well as target dates and titles of the officials responsible for implementation. It should also clearly indicate the dollar value of questioned costs that you plan to either allow or disallow. Please also provide the status of any recommendation repeated from a previous audit. If a recommendation has already been implemented, provide documentation confirming that the action is complete. Please send your response to [email protected]. We will notify Congress about our findings, and we will report semiannually, as required by law, on actions you have taken to implement the recommendations and on recommendations that have not been implemented. We will also post a public version of this report on our website. If you have any questions regarding this report, please contact me at 202–208–5745. Office of Audits, Inspections, and Evaluations | Herndon, VA Contents Introduction......................................................................................................................................1 Objectives ..................................................................................................................................1 Background ................................................................................................................................1 Results of Audit ...............................................................................................................................2 Questioned Costs—$813,801 (Federal Share)...........................................................................2 Control Deficiency.....................................................................................................................9 Finding Repeated From Previous Audit ....................................................................................9 Recommendations Summary .........................................................................................................11 Appendix 1: Scope and Methodology............................................................................................16 Appendix 2: Sites Reviewed ..........................................................................................................19 Appendix 3: Monetary Impact.......................................................................................................20 Appendix 4: Other Direct Cost Deficiencies .................................................................................22 Appendix 5: Responses to Draft Report ........................................................................................23 Appendix 6: Status of Recommendations .....................................................................................31 Introduction Objectives In June 2016, we entered into an intra-agency agreement with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) to conduct audits of State agencies receiving grant funds under the Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program (WSFR). These audits assist the FWS in fulfilling its statutory responsibility to oversee State agencies’ use of these grant funds. The objectives of this audit were to determine whether the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources (Department) used grant funds for allowable fish and wildlife activities and complied with applicable laws and regulations, FWS guidelines, and grant agreements. See Appendix 1 for details about our scope and methodology. See Appendix 2 for sites we reviewed. Background The FWS provides grants to States1 through WSFR for the conservation, restoration, and management of wildlife and sport fish resources as well as educational and recreational activities. WSFR was established by the Pittman-Robertson Wildlife Restoration Act and the Dingell-Johnson Sport Fish Restoration Act.2 The Acts and related Federal regulations allow the FWS to reimburse grantees a portion of eligible costs incurred under WSFR grants—up to 75 percent for States and up to 100 percent for the Commonwealths, territories, and the District of Columbia.3 The reimbursement amount is called the Federal share. The Acts require that hunting and fishing license revenue be used only for the administration of participating fish and wildlife agencies. In addition, Federal regulations require participants to account for any income earned from grant-funded activities and to spend this income before requesting grant reimbursements. 1 Federal regulations define the term “State” as the 50 States, the Commonwealths of Puerto Rico and the Northern Mariana Islands; the territories of Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and American Samoa; and the District of Columbia (Dingell-Johnson Sport Fish Restoration Act only). 2 Formally known, respectively, as the Federal Aid in Wildlife Restoration Act, 16 U.S.C. § 669, as amended, and the Federal Aid in Sport Fish Restoration Act, 16 U.S.C. § 777, as amended. 3 The District of Columbia does not receive funding under the Pittman-Robertson Wildlife Restoration Act. 1 Results of Audit We determined that the Department did not ensure that grant funds were used for allowable fish and wildlife activities and did not comply with all applicable laws and regulations, FWS guidelines, and grant agreements. We found the following: • Questioned Costs. We questioned $807,321 (all Federal share) as unsupported and $6,480 (all Federal share) as unallowable, for a total of $813,801 (see Figure 1). These questioned costs arose due to issues related to unsupported indirect costs and other direct costs, insufficient support for drawdowns, and failure to properly allocate employee leave payouts. • Repeat Finding. We previously reported on inadequate equipment management and found that this issue had not been resolved. Figure 1: Summary of Questioned Costs Totaling $813,801 Unallowable Unsupported Issue Costs ($) Costs ($) Unsupported indirect costs – 435,624 Unsupported other direct costs – 201,708 Insufficient drawdown support – 169,989 Unallocated leave payouts 6,480 – Totals $6,480 $807,321 See Appendix 3 for a statement of monetary impact. Questioned Costs—$813,801 (Federal Share) Unsupported Indirect Costs—Questioned Costs of $435,624 The Department could not provide documentation showing which costs were included in the indirect cost rate that it charged to grants. We reviewed samples of direct costs and indirect costs charged to grants and determined that the Department charged direct costs to grants for goods and services that are usually included in the indirect cost rate. Without documentation showing what costs were included in the indirect cost rate, we could not verify whether the Department charged the grants for expenses as both direct and indirect costs. Therefore, we are questioning all indirect costs within our audit scope, which total $435,624 (see Figure 2). 2 Figure 2: Questioned Costs Related to Unsupported Indirect Costs 3 Grant No. Grant Title Unsupported Costs ($) F17AF01311 F17AF01312 F17AF01313 F17AF01314 F17AF01315 F17AF01316 F17AF01320 F18AF00053 F18AF00055 F18AF00074 F18AF00172 F18AF00175 F18AF00176 F18AF00194 F18AF01141 F18AF01142 F18AF01143 F18AF01144 F18AF01145 F18AF01146 F18AF01147 F18AF01148 F18AF01149 F18AF01150 F18AF01151 F18AF01152 F18AF01153 F18AF01154 F18AF01155 Christmas Cove Mooring Technical Guidance Sport Fish Restoration (SFR) Coordination SFR Offshore Cay Refuge Dredging Red Hook Dock Technical Guidance Wildlife (WL) Coordination WL Recreational Fishery Project Artificial Reefs Program Aquatic Education Sport Fish Enhancement Using Fish Aggregating Devices Red Mangrove (Rhizophora Mangle) Project at Altona Lagoon Fisheries Operations and Maintenance Project Operations and Maintenance WL Aquatic Education: St. Croix Aquatic Education: St. Thomas Boating Access Christmas Cove Moorings Coordination SFR Sport Fish Enhancement Using Fish Aggregating Devices Recreational Fishery Program Red Mangrove Project Operation and Maintenance SFR Technical Guidance SFR Offshore Cay Refuge Coordination WL Hunter Education Technical Guidance WL Operation and Maintenance WL 3,911 2,414 41,499 13,945 4,263 3,761 29,683 8,921 2,667 13,173 34,034 2,491 27,812 23,238 741 3,002 4,415 3,616 47,275 16,899 5,181 7,442 29,815 2,171 7,884 44,865 18,119 4,539 27,848 Total $435,624 Indirect costs are expenses such as overhead or administrative costs that are not traceable to a specific grant or cost center but are allocable to grants. Federal regulations at 2 C.F.R. § 200.403(d) state that a cost may not be charged to a Federal award as a direct cost if the cost has already been allocated to the Federal award as an indirect cost. Also, per 2 C.F.R. § 200.333, a State agency must retain financial records, supporting documents, statistical records, and all other records pertinent to a Federal award for a period of 3 years after submission of the final expenditure report. In addition, if a State agency is audited, it must retain records until the audit concludes, even if the audit extends beyond the 3-year retention period. Further, the Department’s Division of Business and Administrative Services’ standard operating procedures (SOPs) require the Department to retain indirect cost rate documentation for 3 years. While the Department had proper policies in place, it did not adhere to them. The Department hired a contractor to calculate its indirect cost rates for State fiscal years 2018 and 2019. When asked for indirect cost rate support, the Department could not provide all documentation for the audit period completed by the contractor because it did not maintain support for the calculations. By not maintaining support showing what costs are included in the indirect cost rate, the Department risks overcharging the Federal Government by charging the same costs to grants both directly and indirectly. Recommendations We recommend that the FWS: 1. Resolve the questioned costs related to unsupported indirect costs totaling $435,624. 2. Work with the Department to develop and implement a mechanism to hold its staff accountable for following Federal regulations related to indirect costs and record retention, and its own SOPs. Unsupported Other Direct Costs—Questioned Costs of $201,708 We found deficiencies in the Department’s records for purchases completed during fiscal years 2018 and 2019 that led us to question costs totaling $201,708 (see Appendix 4 for deficiencies by grant). Specifically, we found transactions for which: • The purchase order, invoice, and amount paid showed differing amounts. • We could not verify managerial approval. • We could not verify payment approval. • The Department did not include adequate cost identification. 4 • Time limitations or cost type made them ineligible. • We could not verify segregation of duties for purchase approval and invoice payment. • We could not verify the charges were related to the grant. • We could not verify completed transactions and off-island travel claims. • We could not verify that the claimed costs were net of discounts and allowances. Figure 3 lists the questioned costs by grant. Figure 3 : Questioned Costs Related to Unsupported Other Direct Costs Grant No. Grant Title Unsupported Costs ($) F15AF01350 F17AF01312 F18AF00055 F18AF00074 F18AF00194 F18AF01148 F18AF01150 F18AF01143 F18AF01144 F18AF01146 F18AF01147 F18AF01149 F18AF01151 F18AF01154 F18AF01155 Hunter Education Technical Guidance Sport Fish Restoration (SFR) Artificial Reef Program Aquatic Education Operations and Maintenance WL Ren Mangrove Project Technical Guidance SFR Boating Access Christmas Cove Moorings Sport Fish Enhancement Using Fish Aggregating Devices Recreational Fishery Program Operations and Maintenance SFR Offshore Cay Refuge Technical Guidance WL Operations and Maintenance WL 85,525 1,850 2,488 1,680 17,715 3,425 1,500 1,687 9,200 30,557 5,780 8,335 18,079 1,000 12,887 Total $201,708 Federal regulations at 2 C.F.R. § 200.403(c) state that costs must be consistent with policies and procedures that apply to both federally financed and other activities of the non-Federal entity. Furthermore, 2 C.F.R. §§ 200.403(g)–200.403(h) state that these costs must be adequately documented and incurred during the approved budget period. In addition, the Department’s Division of Business and Administrative Services’ SOPs require the Department to maintain the following documentation for completed transactions: (1) the signed and verified request for 5 purchase, (2) the requisition generated by its financial system, (3) the signed purchase order, (4) the vendor invoice with certifying receipt of goods and services along with the invoice generated by its financial system, and (5) the check disbursement proof from its financial system. The Department was unable to provide us with complete records of its purchases because it did not consistently follow Federal guidance and its own departmental requirements for procuring goods and services and documenting those purchases. Further, the Department had staff turnover during the audit scope period, which may have affected the completeness of records. Without adequate documentation for purchases, the FWS cannot determine whether costs charged to grants are reasonable, allowable, approved, and necessary to achieve the intended purpose of the grant. Recommendations We recommend that the FWS: 3. Resolve the questioned costs related to unsupported other direct costs totaling $201,708. 4. Work with the Department to develop a mechanism to hold staff accountable for following its SOPs related to purchase requests and documentation retention. Insufficient Drawdown Support—Questioned Costs of $169,989 The Department’s accounting system did not contain support for the expenditures for which it requested reimbursement from the FWS. We reviewed a sample of 16 WSFR grants to verify whether the Department’s requests for reimbursement (drawdowns) were reasonable, consistent with need, and based on expenditures incurred. When we attempted to reconcile the drawdown documentation with the expenditure amounts posted in the accounting system, the amounts did not match. After we made multiple attempts to obtain further documentation to support the reimbursement amounts, the Department provided us a reconciliation it had performed. Even with this additional information, we could not verify the information in the Department’s accounting system for drawdowns on 7 out of 16 grants we reviewed. When we asked the Department to demonstrate how it performed the reconciliation on these 7 grants, it could not reperform the reconciliation in the accounting system. We could not verify that the Department paid expenditures before requesting reimbursement; therefore, we questioned $169,989 as unsupported reimbursements (see Figure 4). 6 Figure 4: Questioned Costs Related to Unsupported Drawdowns Unsupported Grant No. Grant Title Costs ($) F16AF01302 Boating Access 83,490 F18AF00172 Sport Fish Enhancement Using Fish Aggregating Devices 31,311 F18AF01145 Coordination Sport Fish Restoration 24,423 F18AF01149 Operation and Maintenance Sport Fish 3,074 F18AF01151 Offshore Cay Refuge 184 F18AF01152 Coordination Wildlife (WL) 20,197 F18AF01155 Operation and Maintenance WL 7,310 Total $169,989 According to 50 C.F.R § 80.83(b), the FWS may reimburse the Department up to 100 percent of grant expenditures, provided the Department expends its funds on grant activity prior to seeking reimbursement. Federal regulations at 2 C.F.R. § 200.302(b)(3) require that records in the Department’s financial management system identify the source and application of funds for federally funded activities. These records must contain information pertaining to Federal awards, authorizations, financial obligations, unobligated balances, assets, expenditures, income, and interest and be supported by source documentation. In addition, the Department’s SOPs state that drawdowns must be reviewed to ensure the costs charged to the Federal grant are allowable and the necessary documentation is in place before they are made. Without proper supporting documentation for drawdowns that can be directly linked to the Department’s accounting system, the FWS is at risk of reimbursing the Department for expenses that were not incurred or are unallowable. Recommendations We recommend that the FWS: 5. Resolve the questioned costs related to drawdowns totaling $169,989. 6. Work with the Department to develop a mechanism to hold staff accountable for following its SOPs for conducting drawdowns and maintaining adequate documentation for expenditures in the accounting system. 7 Unallocated Leave Payouts—Questioned Costs of $6,480 Two Department employees separated from government service during our audit scope, and the Department did not correctly allocate their leave payouts. Upon separation, the Department charged the full amount of the employees’ lump sum leave payouts to two WSFR grants instead of allocating the cost to all grants and activities the employees worked on during the audit period; therefore, we question the leave payouts, totaling $6,480 (see Figure 5). Figure 5: Questioned Costs Related to Unallocated Leave Payouts Grant No. Grant Title Unallowable Costs ($) F17AF01316 F18AF01151 Technical Guidance Program Offshore Cay Refuge 6,432 48 Total $6,480 Federal regulations at 2 C.F.R. § 200.431(b) state that the costs of fringe benefits in the form of regular compensation paid to employees during periods of authorized absences from the job, such as for annual leave and other similar benefits, are allowable if the costs are equitably allocated to all related activities, including Federal awards. The Department told us that there was a change in administration during the time the leave payouts were made. We determined that the SOPs did not satisfy Federal regulations related to leave payouts. Department staff said the new administration will be making policy changes; however, the SOPs have yet to be updated to reflect the changes. According to the timesheets, the employees worked and earned leave on other Federal program awards and Territory-funded activities in addition to WSFR grants during the audit period. Those additional activities contributed to the accrued leave payout costs, which should have been allocated accordingly. Not properly allocating leave payouts among all applicable grants can impact grant efficiency by diverting funds that could otherwise be used for grant objectives. Recommendations We recommend that the FWS: 7. Resolve the questioned costs related to unallocated leave payouts totaling $6,480. 8. Require the Department to update and implement its SOPs to ensure that leave payouts are properly allocated in accordance with Federal regulations. 8 Control Deficiency Inadequate Equipment Management The Department did not maintain a complete and accurate equipment inventory. During our current audit, we received an inventory list from the Department’s field offices and compared it with the master list we received from the Department of Property and Procurement (DPP), the property manager for the U.S. Virgin Islands. Our comparison showed discrepancies between the two lists. Specifically, there were items on the Department’s inventory list that had not been added to the DPP’s inventory list. Federal regulations require that each State follow its own policies and procedures for the use, management, and control of its equipment. Specifically, 50 C.F.R. § 80.90(f) states that State fish and wildlife agencies are responsible for assets acquired under program grants to ensure that they serve the intended purpose throughout their useful life. According to 2 C.F.R. § 200.313(d)(1), property records must include a description of the property, identification number, the source of funding (including the Federal Award Identification Number), acquisition date, cost of the property, and the location. The Department’s SOPs duplicate the language from the Federal regulation at 2 C.F.R. § 200.313(d)(1) but also include language requiring that the Department’s consolidated inventory be reconciled with the DPP’s master inventory list. When asked, the DPP stated it had not performed a physical inventory or reconciliation for the Department in the past 6 years due to staffing shortages and to shifting priorities due to two major hurricanes. Without reconciling its list, the Department cannot ensure its equipment inventory is accurate and equipment is being used for authorized purposes. Recommendation We recommend that the FWS: 9. Ensure the Department allocates resources and prioritizes the reconciliation of its inventory list with the DPP as required by Federal regulations and the Department’s SOPs; this should include establishing a plan with milestones. Finding Repeated From Previous Audit We found that the Department’s property records were missing property tags, acquisition dates, serial numbers, cost documentation, grant titles, and grant numbers. In a previous audit of costs claimed by the Department on WSFR grants for fiscal years 2009 and 2010 (Report No. R–GR– FWS–0006–2011), we found that the Department’s property records for equipment acquired with WSFR grant funds did not include the required information for all items.4 In our subsequent 4 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program Grants Awarded to the Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2008, Through September 30, 2010 (Report No. R–GR–FWS–0006–2011), issued November 2011. 9 audit for fiscal years 2013 and 2014 (Report No. 2016–EXT–005), we found this issue was again unresolved.5 Federal regulations at 2 C.F.R. § 200.313(d)(1) require State agencies to maintain property records that include a description; a serial number or other identification number; the source of funding (including the Federal Award Identification Number); who holds the title; the acquisition date; the cost; the percentage of Federal participation in the project costs; the location, use, and condition; and any ultimate disposition data including the date of disposal and sale price. Although the Department does have a process in place to track equipment acquired with WSFR funds and has submitted documents to close the recommendation, the FWS has determined that the Department’s records cannot be reconciled without a site visit to verify all information and documentation. The FWS anticipates conducting a site visit to the close the recommendation in early 2022. There is a risk that inadequate recordkeeping of equipment can lead to a misappropriation of assets and noncompliance with Federal regulations. As a result, the Department may not be able to prevent equipment purchased with WSFR funds from being lost, misplaced, or used for unauthorized purposes. Repeat Recommendation (Tracked Under Report No. R–GR–FWS–0006–2011, Recommendation D) We recommend that the FWS: • Require the Department to follow its own SOPs, which state that all required items be included in its asset management database. 5 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program Grants Awarded to the Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2021, Through September 30, 2014 (Report No. 2016–EXT–005), issued February 2017. 10 11 Recommendations Summary We provided a draft of this report to the FWS for review. The FWS concurred with all recommendations and will work with the Department to implement corrective actions. We consider Recommendations 1–9 and our repeat recommendation resolved but not implemented. See Appendix 5 for the full text of the FWS’ and the Department’s responses; Appendix 6 lists the status of each recommendation. We recommend that the FWS: 1. Resolve the questioned costs related to unsupported indirect costs totaling $435,624. Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that “the cost tracking was not understood clearly by OIG auditors” and that it “was not informed that all open grants were included (from the years before and after the audit period).” The Department also stated that it “can provide the cost tracking information in another format if needed” and that “all indirect costs were supportive of grant objectives.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 1 resolved but not implemented. We reviewed the Department’s SOPs for indirect cost guidance and clearly understood the Department’s procedure for cost tracking; however, the Department could not provide documentation showing how indirect cost were allotted. In our engagement letter, dated September 24, 2020, we stated that the audit period covered State fiscal years 2018–2019 (October 1, 2017, to September 30, 2019). This includes all grants that were open during this timeframe, whether they were opened or closed during the audit period. All grants included are listed in Figure 2 of this report. Furthermore, during the progress of the audit, we requested records to support that the administrative and other overhead costs that we found in both the list of direct and indirect costs were not double counted. We also issued a Notice of Potential Finding and Recommendation on June 7, 2021, again seeking further information and did not receive a reply. 2. Work with the Department to develop and implement a mechanism to hold its staff accountable for following Federal regulations related to indirect costs and record retention, and its own SOPs. Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that it did “maintain internal records.” The Department further stated that its “ being on extended leave during the audit may have resulted in communications issues amongst Department staff, accounting staff, and the auditors.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 2 resolved but not implemented. The Department was not able to provide supporting documentation for the calculation of indirect costs. The recommendation will be considered implemented when the Department provides documentation demonstrating that it has developed and implemented a mechanism to hold its staff accountable for following Federal regulations related to indirect costs and record retention, and its own SOPs. 3. Resolve the questioned costs related to unsupported other direct costs totaling $201,708. Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that all documentation “related to the direct costs was provided to the auditors initially.” The Department also provided additional documentation as justification for direct cost along with its response to the draft report. FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 3 resolved but not implemented. We reviewed the documentation the Department provided in its response and found additional supporting evidence, which reduced questioned costs from $289,486 to $201,708. However, the additional information did not resolve all findings. Some of the documentation provided was the same documentation received during the audit and still lacked specific details like payment approval, management approval, or the transactions being related to the purpose of the grant. 4. Work with the Department to develop a mechanism to hold staff accountable for following its SOPs related to purchase requests and documentation retention. Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that all “staff do follow SOPs related to purchase requests and documentation retention.” The Department stated that “communication issues prevented it from providing complete supporting documentation.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 4 resolved but not implemented. The recommendation will be considered implemented when the Department provides documentation demonstrating that it has developed and implemented a mechanism to hold its staff accountable for following its SOPs related to purchase requests and documentation retention. 5. Resolve the questioned costs related to drawdowns totaling $169,989. Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, referencing a communication issue that led to a “disconnect with the accounting department.” The Department also provided additional supporting documentation. 12 FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 5 resolved but not implemented. We reviewed the additional documentation the Department submitted and determined it was not sufficient to support the drawdowns because it did not include the expenditure transactional data. 6. Work with the Department to develop a mechanism to hold staff accountable for following its SOPs for conducting drawdowns and maintaining adequate documentation for expenditures in the accounting system. Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, again referencing a communication issue due to its being on leave during the audit. The Department stated that it adhered to its SOPs and “that all monies were reported related to drawdowns.” The Department also provided additional supporting documentation. FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 6 resolved but not implemented. We reviewed the additional documentation the Department submitted and determined that it did not sufficiently support the drawdowns because we could not verify the expenditure transactional data. The recommendation will be considered implemented when the Department provides documentation demonstrating that it has developed and implemented a mechanism to hold its staff accountable for following its SOPs for conducting drawdowns and maintaining adequate documentation for expenditures in the accounting system. 7. Resolve the questioned costs related to unallocated leave payouts totaling $6,480 Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with this recommendation, stating that “all leave payouts will be allocated to the indirect cost budget.” The Department further stated that it supplied the indirect cost budget, which indicated “where the leave payouts were paid to employees.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 7 resolved but not implemented. The recommendation will be considered implemented when the Department provides documentation demonstrating that it has resolved the questioned costs related to unallocated leave payouts. 13 8. Require the Department to update and implement its SOPs to ensure that leave payouts are properly allocated in accordance with Federal regulations Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that “all staff leave payouts will come from the indirect cost budget.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 8 resolved but not implemented. The recommendation will be considered implemented when the Department provides documentation demonstrating that it has updated its SOPs to ensure that leave payouts are properly allocated. 9. Ensure the Department allocates resources and prioritizes the reconciliation of its inventory list with the DPP as required by Federal regulations and the Department’s SOPs; this should include establishing a plan with milestones Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that “due to staffing capacity, the DPP has not been able to reconcile their property lists.” The Department also stated that “the DPP will be removed from [its] SOP as is allowable under 50 C.F.R. § 80.90(f) which requires the [Department] only to be responsible for its assets.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation. OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider Recommendation 9 resolved but not implemented. We reviewed inventory lists from the Department and the DPP and found that they were not consistent. The recommendation will be considered implemented when the Department provides documentation demonstrating that it has updated its SOPs to reflect that the DPP was removed as the responsible party for Department’s inventory. Repeat Recommendation (Tracked Under Report No. R–GR–FWS–0006–2011, Recommendation D) We recommend that the FWS: • Require the Department to follow its own SOPs, which state that all required items be included in its asset management database Department Response: The Department did not express whether it concurred with the recommendation, stating that “none of the equipment purchased in the years after the last audit was missing information and the issue was resolved.” The Department further stated that “OIG auditors requested the full, current physical inventory list from the [Department]; some items were listed which were purchased more than 3 years prior to 14 the current audit period so the information reflected the previously acknowledged audit finding.” FWS Response: The FWS concurred with our recommendation OIG Reply: Based on the FWS’ response, we consider this recommendation resolved but not implemented. As previously stated, the FWS determined that the Department’s records cannot be reconciled without a site visit to verify all information and documentation. The FWS anticipates conducting a site visit to the close the recommendation in 2022. 15 Appendix 1: Scope and Methodology Scope We audited the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources’ (Department’s) use of grants awarded by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) under the Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program (WSFR). We reviewed 39 grants that were open during the State fiscal years that ended September 30, 2018, and September 30, 2019. The audit included expenditures of $4.2 million and related transactions. Because of the COVID-19 pandemic, we could not complete our audit on site. We gathered data remotely and communicated with Department personnel via email and telephone. We could not perform the equipment verification and review of grant projects specific to construction and restoration work in person; therefore, we relied on pictorial evidence provided by Department personnel. Methodology We conducted this performance audit in accordance with generally accepted government auditing standards. Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain sufficient, appropriate evidence to provide a reasonable basis for our findings and conclusions based on our audit objective. We believe that the evidence obtained provides a reasonable basis for our findings and conclusions based on our audit objective. We assessed whether internal control was significant to the audit objective. We determined that the State’s control activities, risk assessment, information and communication and the following related principles were significant to the audit objectives. • Management should design control activities to achieve objectives and respond to risks. • Management should design the entity’s information system and related control activities to achieve objectives and respond to risks. • Management should implement control activities through policies. • Management should define objectives clearly to enable the identification of risks and define risk tolerances. • Management should identify, analyze, and respond to risks related to achieving the defined objectives. • Management should consider the potential for fraud when identifying, analyzing, and responding to risks. 16 • Management should identify, analyze, and respond to significant changes that could impact the internal control. • Management should internally communicate the necessary quality information to achieve the entity’s objectives. We tested the operation and reliability of internal control over activities related to our audit objective. Our tests and procedures included: • Examining the evidence that supports selected expenditures charged to the grants by the Department. • Reviewing transactions related to purchases, direct costs, and drawdowns of reimbursements. • Interviewing Department employees. • Using photographic evidence to inspect equipment and other property. • Determining whether the Territory passed required legislation assenting to the provisions of the Pittman-Robertson Wildlife Restoration Act and the Dingell-Johnson Sport Fish Restoration Act. • Evaluating Territory policies and procedures for assessing risk and monitoring subawards. • Virtually visiting sites throughout the Territory (see Appendix 2 for a list of sites visited). We found deficiencies in internal control resulting in our five findings of unsupported indirect costs, unsupported other direct costs, insufficient support for drawdowns, unallocated leave payouts, and inadequate equipment management. Based on the results of our initial assessments, we assigned a level of risk and selected a judgmental sample of transactions for testing. We used auditor judgment and considered risk levels relative to other audit work performed to determine the degree of testing performed in each area. Our sample selections were not generated using statistical sampling, and therefore we did not project the results of our tests to the total population of transactions. This audit supplements, but does not replace, the audits required by the Single Audit Act Amendments of 1996. Single audit reports address controls over Statewide financial reporting, with emphasis on major programs. Our report focuses on the administration of the U.S. Virgin Islands fish and wildlife agency, and that agency’s management of WSFR resources and license revenue. The Department provided computer-generated data from its official accounting system and from informal management information and reporting systems. We tested the data by sampling 17 expenditures and verifying them against WSFR reports and source documents such as purchase orders, invoices, and payroll documentation. While we assessed the accuracy of the transactions tested, we did not assess the reliability of the accounting system as a whole. Prior Audit Coverage OIG Audit Reports We reviewed our last two audits of costs claimed by the Department on WSFR grants.6 We followed up on 20 recommendations from these reports and found that the U.S. Department of the Interior’s Office of Policy, Management and Budget considered 19 recommendations to be resolved and implemented. As discussed in the “Results of Audit” section in this report, we are repeating one recommendation, which relates to inadequate equipment management. Territory Audit Reports We reviewed the single audit reports for fiscal years 2017 and 2018 to identify control deficiencies or other reportable conditions that affect WSFR. In those reports, the Schedule of Expenditures of Federal Awards (SEFA) indicated $3.8 million (combined) in Federal expenditures related to WSFR, but did not include any findings directly related to WSFR, which was not deemed a major program for Territorywide audit purposes. Neither of these reports contained any findings that would directly affect WSFR grants. We also reviewed a 2018 report from the Territory public auditor that found issues with controls with the SEFA, Federal grants and contributions, payroll, back accounts, and the IT environment. 6 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program Grants Awarded to the Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1 2008, Through September 30, 2010 (Report No. R–GR–FWS–0006–2011), dated November 2011. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program Grants Awarded to the Government of the Virgin Islands, Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1 2012, Through September 30, 2014 (Report No. 2016–EXT–005), dated February 2017. 18 Appendix 2: Sites Reviewed Regional Offices Rainbow Plaza at Mars Hill – St. Croix Red Hook – St. Thomas Boating Access Facility Frederiksted Ramp – St. Croix Hunter Education Facility Lagrange Archery Field – St. Croix 19 Appendix 3: Monetary Impact We reviewed 39 grants that were open during the State fiscal years that ended September 30, 2018, and September 30, 2019. The audit included expenditures of $4.2 million and related transactions. We questioned costs in the amount of $813,801 (all Federal share). Monetary Impact: Questioned Costs 20 Questioned Grant No. Grant Title Cost Category Costs ($) F17AF01311 Christmas Cove Mooring Indirect Cost 3,911 F17AF01312 Technical Guidance Sport Fish Restoration (SFR) Indirect Cost 2,414 F17AF01313 Coordination SFR Indirect Cost 41,499 F17AF01314 Offshore Cay Refuge Indirect Cost 13,945 F17AF01315 Dredging Red Hook Dock Indirect Cost 4,263 F17AF01316 Technical Guidance Wildlife (WL) Indirect Cost 3,761 F17AF01320 Coordination WL Indirect Cost 29,683 F18AF00053 Recreational Fishery Project Indirect Cost 8,921 F18AF00055 Artificial Reefs Program Indirect Cost 2,667 F18AF00076 Aquatic Education Indirect Cost 13,173 F18AF00172 Sport Fish Enhancement Using Fish Aggregating Devices Indirect Cost 34,034 F18AF00175 Red Mangrove (Rhizophora Mangle) Project at Altona Lagoon Indirect Cost 2,491 F18AF00176 Fisheries Operations and Maintenance Project Indirect Cost 27,812 F18AF00194 Operations and Maintenance WL Indirect Cost 23,238 F18AF01141 Aquatic Education: St. Croix Indirect Cost 741 F18AF01142 Aquatic Education: St. Thomas Indirect Cost 3,002 F18AF01143 Boating Access Indirect Cost 4,415 F18AF01144 Christmas Cove Moorings Indirect Cost 3,616 F18AF01145 Coordination SFR Indirect Cost 47,275 Sport Fish (SF) Enhancement F18AF01146 Using Fish Aggregating Devices Indirect Cost 16,899 (FADS) F18AF01147 Recreational Fishery Program Indirect Cost 5,181 F18AF01148 Red Mangrove Project Indirect Cost 7,442 F18AF01149 Operation and Maintenance SFR Indirect Cost 29,815 F18AF01150 Technical Guidance SFR Indirect Cost 2,171 F18AF01151 Offshore Cay Refuge Indirect Cost 7,884 Grant No. Grant Title Cost Category Questioned Costs ($) F18AF01152 F18AF01153 F18AF01154 F18AF01155 F15AF01350 F17AF01312 F18AF00055 F18AF00074 F18AF00194 F18AF01148 F18AF01150 F18AF01143 F18AF01144 F18AF01146 F18AF01147 F18AF01149 F18AF01151 F18AF01154 F18AF01155 F16AF01302 F18AF00172 F18AF01145 F18AF01149 F18AF01151 F18AF01152 F18AF01155 F17AF01316 F18AF01151 Coordination WL Hunter Education Technical Guidance WL Operation and Maintenance WL Hunter Education Technical Guidance SFR Artificial Reef Program Aquatic Education Operations and Maintenance WL Ren Mangrove Project Technical Guidance SFR Boating Access Christmas Cove Moorings SF Enhancement FADS Recreational Fishery Program Operations and Maintenance SFR Offshore Cay Refuge Technical Guidance WL Operations and Maintenance WL Boating Access SF Enhancement Using FADS Coordination SFR Operation and Maintenance SF Offshore Cay Refuge Coordination WL Operation and Maintenance WL Technical Guidance Program Offshore Cay Refuge Indirect Cost Indirect Cost Indirect Cost Indirect Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Other Direct Cost Drawdowns Drawdowns Drawdowns Drawdowns Drawdowns Drawdowns Drawdowns Payroll Payroll 44,865 18,119 4,539 27,848 85,525 1,850 2,488 1,680 17,715 3,425 1,500 1,687 9,200 30,557 5,780 8,335 18,079 1,000 12,887 83,490* 31,311* 24,423* 3,074* 184* 20,197* 7,310* 6,432 48 Total $813,801 * These may be duplicative of costs already questioned in other cost categories because the Department could not provide the details of the unsupported drawdown differences. Therefore, we could not identify the specific cost categories within the drawdowns, which included expenditures associated with indirect costs, other direct costs, and payroll expenses. 21 Appendix 4: Other Direct Cost Deficiencies Deficiency Type ( X = Present) 22 Grant No. Grant Title A B C D E F G H I F15AF01350 Hunter Education X X X X X F16AF01302 Boating Access X X X X F17AF01320 Coordination WL X X X F17AF01312 Technical Guidance SFR X X X F18AF00055 Artificial Reef Program X X F18AF00074 Aquatic Education X X X F18AF00194 Operation and Maintenance WL X X X X F18AF01143 Boating Access X X X F18AF01144 Christmas Cove Moorings X X X X X F18AF01146 SF Enhancement FADS X X X X X X X X F18AF01147 Recreational Fishery Program X X X X F18AF01148 Ren Mangrove Project X X X X F18AF01149 Operation and Maintenance SF X X X X X X X X X F18AF01150 Technical Guidance SFR X X X X F18AF01151 Offshore Cay Refuge X X X X F18AF01154 Technical Guidance WL X X X X F18AF01155 Operation and Maintenance WL X X X X X X X X X Deficiency key: A. The purchase order, invoice, and payment amounts were different. B. We could not verify managerial approval. C. We could not verify payment approval. D. The Department did not include adequate cost identification. E. Time limitations or cost type made them ineligible. F. We could not verify segregation of duties for purchase approval and invoice payment. G. We could not verify the charges were related to the grant. H. We could not verify completed transactions and off-island travel claims. I. We could not verify that the claimed costs were net of discounts and allowances. Appendix 5: Responses to Draft Report The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s response to our draft report follows on page 25. The U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources’ response to our draft report follows on page 26. 23 United States Department of the Interior FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE 1875 Century Blvd Atlanta, Georgia 30345 March 17, 2022 IN REPLY REFER TO: FWS/R2/R4/WSFR Nicki Miller, Regional Manager, Eastern Region U.S. Department of the Interior Office of Inspector General 381 Elden Street, Suite 3000 Herndon, VA 20170 Re: Draft Audit Report -U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Grants Awarded to the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2017, Through September 30, 2019, Under the Wildlife and Sport Fish Restoration Program Repo1i No. 2021-ER-002, Issued December 21, 2021 Dear Ms. Miller: The enclosed response to the draft audit repo1i referenced above was developed by the U.S. Virgin Islands Depa1iment of Planning and Natural Resources, in cooperation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Se1vice South Atlantic - Gulf and Mississippi Basin Unified Regions Wildlife and Spo1i Fish Restoration Program. questions or need additional info1mation, please contact Alex Coley at ___ _ Sincerely, S ignature - Paul Wilkes Digitally signed by PAUL WILKES Date: 2022.03.17 16:32:51 -04'00' Paul A. Wilkes, Regional Manager Wildlife and Spo1i Fish Restoration Enclosure Cc: Ord Bargerstock, Shuwen Cheung Division of Financial Assistance Supp01i and Oversight 25 Response to Draft Report U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE WILDLIFE AND SPORT FISH RESTORATION PROGRAM Grants Awarded to the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources, From October 1, 2017, Through September 30, 2019 Draft Report No. 2021-ER-002, Issued December 21, 2021 Auditor Recommendation 1 The auditors recommend that the FWS Resolve the questioned costs related to unsupported indirect costs totaling $435,624. Agency Response The State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW believes that the cost tracking was not understood clearly by OIG auditors. The State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW did request the itemized costs from OIG and they were not provided so we could not communicate that grants were open before and after the years requested; the State Fish & Wildlife Agency was not informed that all open grants were included (from the years before and after the audit period) –our sum for FY18 and FY19 IDC is $217,653. The State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW can provide the cost tracking information in another format if needed. All indirect costs were supportive of grant objectives. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. Auditor Recommendation 2 The auditors recommend that the FWS work with the Department to develop and implement a mechanism to hold its staff accountable for following Federal regulations related to indirect costs and record retention, and its own SOPs. Agency Response The State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW does maintain internal records. The State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW provided the contract with the IDC contractor to the federal OIG and the local Office of Management and Budget, and it is provided in the email attachment. DPNR-DFW’s being on extended leave during the audit may have resulted in communication issues among Department staff, accounting staff, and the auditors. We believe we adhere to our SOPs and communication issues prevented us from supplying complete documentation packages. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. 26 1 Auditor Recommendation 3 The auditors recommend that the FWS resolve the questioned costs related to unsupported other direct costs totaling $289,486. Agency Response All documentation including purchase orders, invoices, managerial approval, payment approval (in the requisition) related to the direct costs was provided to the auditors initially and is provided again in the email attachments for questioned costs. All direct costs are directly supported with paperwork. Only the payment information was requested and was sent by email and Sharepoint to OIG. All direct costs justification information is available; for questioned costs, the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW have submitted the documentation in the email attachment. All direct costs were reviewed according to the SOP by the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW Grants Manager, Assistant Director of the Business Office, and the Directors of the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR DFW and Business and Administrative Services to ensure purchases support grant objectives. There is a paper copy of the Request for Purchase ‘Description’ detailing the purchase retained in the Red Hook and Mars Hill State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW offices. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. Auditor Recommendation 4 The auditors recommend that the FWS work with the Department to develop a mechanism to hold staff accountable for following its SOPs related to purchase requests and documentation retention. Agency Response All State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW staff do follow the SOPs related to purchase requests and documentation retention. In the future, the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW will provide all five of the items detailed in the draft Audit Report at the inception of the request by auditors. DPNR DFW’s was on extended leave during the audit, resulting in a communication disconnect with the accounting department. We believe we adhere to our SOPs and communication issues prevented us from supplying complete documentation packages. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. Auditor Recommendation 5 The auditors recommend that the FWS resolve the questioned costs related to drawdowns totaling $169,989. 27 2 Agency Response DPNR-DFW’s was on extended leave during the audit, resulting in a communication disconnect with the accounting department. We believe we have the documentation to support all draws and communication issues prevented us from supplying a complete documentation package. The FFR and Flex Period reports indicate that all monies were reported related to drawdowns. In some cases, the grants were extended beyond FY19 and approved by USFWS to allow for close-out procedures. The difference in amounts indicated in the questioned costs of the draft audit report were due to the request by OIG for a data dump time period from the Department of Finance differing from the time period of the grant expiration dates when extensions were requested by the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW. Please refer to all FFR for the expiration dates. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. Auditor Recommendation 6 The auditors recommend that the FWS work with the Department to develop a mechanism to hold staff accountable for following its SOPs for conducting drawdowns and maintaining adequate documentation for expenditures in the accounting system. Agency Response DPNR-DFW’s was on extended leave during the audit, resulting in a communication disconnect with the accounting department. We believe we adhere to our SOPs and communication issues prevented us from supplying complete documentation packages. The FFR and Flex Period reports indicate that all monies were reported related to drawdowns. The State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR- DFW followed all SOP. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. Auditor Recommendation 7 The auditors recommend that the FWS resolve the questioned costs related to unallocated leave payouts totaling $6,480. Agency Response Moving forward, all leave payouts will be allocated to the indirect cost budget. The IDC budget was supplied to the auditors indicating where the leave payouts were paid to employees. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. 3 28 Auditor Recommendation 8 The auditors recommend that the FWS require the Department to update and implement its SOPs to ensure that leave payouts are properly allocated in accordance with Federal regulations. Agency Response All staff leave payouts will come from the indirect cost budget. Service Response The Service concurs with the auditor’s recommendation. Auditor Recommendation 9 The auditors recommend that the FWS ensure the Department allocates resources and prioritizes the reconciliation of its inventory list with the DPP as required by Federal regulations and the Department’s SOPs; this should include establishing a plan with milestones. Agency Response The Department of Property and Procurement (DPP) is a property manager of the Government of the Virgin Islands that works in parallel to the property managers of the State Fish and Wildlife agency DPNR-DFW. Due to staffing capacity, the DPP has not been able to reconcile their property lists to those of DPNR-DFW. However, all items were located from the DPNR-DFW physical inventory list. The auditors did not request anything from the DPP inventory list during the video interviews that DPNR DFW facilitated based on the OIG Inventory Samples. The lists provided by DPP to OIG were more than 6 years old as both OIG and DPNR-DFW stated in the Notice of Potential Findings and Recommendations No. 1. The DPP will be removed from the DPNR SOP as is allowable under 50 C.F. R 80.90(f) which requires the State Fish and Wildlife agency (DPNR-DFW) only to be responsible for its assets. Repeat Recommendation (Tracked Under Report No. R-GR-FWS-0006-2011, Recommendation D) None of the equipment purchased in the years after the last audit was missing information and the issue was resolved. The OIG auditors requested the full, current physical inventory list from the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW; some items were listed which were purchased more than 3 years prior to the current audit period so the information reflected the previously acknowledged audit finding. This was already acknowledged by the State Fish & Wildlife Agency DPNR-DFW and was indicated as in the example below: 29 4 Table listing inventory based on condition, description, room location, grant funding and value. The Room Location has been redacted. 45074 TACNO. • DESCRIPilON COJ\'."DmON • VALUE(S)• Loca 150415 2 016 Chevrolet Colorado Good S 36,439 00 Red Hook 150138 2017 Chevrolet Trav rse G d S 33, Red Hook 0125103 Lapt op Excellent $ 4,004 00 Red Hook 0125102 Lapt op Excellent $ 4,004 00 Red Hook 011903 Printer Fair s 3 899 00 Red Hook 150393 2<1Shi in Container s 3 70000 Red Hook 0116884 Printer s 2,097 00 Red Hook Phone 99900 Red Hook Red Hook Red Hook Tou com uter P.:urchased do, Red Hook P.:urchased rior.tQ,.2020 Red Hook 2 014 Chevrolet Silverado P.:urchased dor. Red Hook 2009 Chevrolet Silverado l!ua:hased do, Red Hook 0118109 TV Good l!ua:hased do, Red Hook 3S746 UW camera housing Fair Purchased nor Red Hook 106203 Notebook com uter Good urchased nor Red Hook unreadable PS Unit ua:hased do< Red Hook Handh Id radio l!ua:hased do< Red Hook unreadable Camera Poor Purchased pJie! Red Hook Service Response The Se1vice concurs with the auditor's recommendation. 5 30 Appendix 6: Status of Recommendations 31 Recommendation Status Action Required 1–9 Repeat Recommendation 1 (Report No. R–GR–FWS– 0006–2011) Resolved but not implemented: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) regional officials concurred with these recommendations and will work with staff from the U.S. Virgin Islands Department of Planning and Natural Resources to develop and implement a corrective action plan. Complete a corrective action plan that includes information on actions taken or planned to address the recommendations, target dates and titles of the officials responsible for implementation, and verification that FWS headquarters officials reviewed and approved the actions the State has taken or planned. D O I OIG logo OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL U.S. DEPARTMENT OFTHE INTERIOR REPORT FRAUD, WASTE, ABUSE, AND MISMANAGEMENT The Office of Inspector General (OIG) provides independent oversight and promotes integrity and accountability in the programs and operations of the U.S. Department of the Interior (DOI). One way we achieve this mission is by working with the people who contact us through our hotline. If you wish to file a complaint about potential fraud, waste, abuse, or mismanagement in the DOI, please visit the OIG’s online hotline at www.doioig.gov/hotline or call the OIG hotline's toll-free number: 1-800-424-5081 Who Can Report? Anyone with knowledge of potential fraud, waste, abuse, misconduct, or mismanagement involving the DOI should contact the OIG hotline. This includes knowledge of potential misuse involving DOI grants and contracts. How Does it Help? Every day, DOI employees and non-employees alike contact the OIG, and the information they share can lead to reviews and investigations that result in accountability and positive change for the DOI, its employees, and the public. Am I protected? Complainants may request confidentiality. The Privacy Act, the Inspector General Act, and other applicable laws protect complainants. Section 7(b) of the Inspector General Act of 1978 states that the Inspector General shall not disclose the identity of a DOI employee who reports an allegation or provides information without the employee’s consent, unless the Inspector General determines that disclosure is unavoidable during the course of the investigation. By law, Federal employees may not take or threaten to take a personnel action because of whistleblowing or the exercise of a lawful appeal, complaint, or grievance right. Non-DOI employees who report allegations may also specifically request confidentiality. |